The theme of the event was about “raising awareness of men's mental health, encouraging open and honest conversations, and breaking down the barriers that prevent men from seeking support.” The speakers spoke bravely and movingly from lived experience and also from professional or charitable working with those who have mental health problems. They gave great advice on self-care, and most of all they emphasised the importance of talking; encouraging men that it's OK to talk about our feelings and struggles (and implicitly encouraging men to listen to someone who does want to share.) I hope that the JLC students who were there really take to heart the message that opening up is not weakness, and asking for help is not weakness.
This event aimed to be a start to the conversation around men's mental health, and I thought that it achieved that aim really well. The number of people who attended was a really encouraging sign that the barriers that prevent men from seeking support are definitely breaking down, and that this conversation is an important one. And so, I'd like to offer the following thoughts as a possible direction that conversation could take. I recognise of course, that one event cannot cover every aspect of a topic, nor any aspect in the depth it could be covered. Also, these comments are not intended as criticisms of what the speakers said, and I apologise if I mis-quote or misinterpret what any of the speakers said – my note-taking skills aren't very good!
My first thought is around talking. This was the main takeaway from the event and in no way do I want to downplay the importance of open and honest conversations around struggles, and also of asking for help. A number of the lived experiences that were shared involved suicides, and it was rightly said that talking saves lives. It is great to share our troubles and often in sharing we find that others have similar experiences, and we can draw strength and encouragement from those who are either going through those struggles or have gone through them. And this is true for all of our struggles, whether they are existential struggles that lead people to contemplate suicide or more mundane, everyday struggles. Perhaps it's especially that latter category that we need to talk about, lest we think that we are the only people that struggle with them. However, my caveat would be that we need to be aware of the limits of talking, precisely because of that common struggle. One of Jesus' sayings that has become part of our language is “If the blind lead the blind, both will fall into a pit” (Matthew 15:14). It is essential that we admit to our struggles and by doing so we learn that we are not alone in our struggles, and we can support each other. Those who are less 'blind' or have found coping mechanisms for their 'blindness' can be a great help, but if we are to move forward, we need someone who can 'see.' Surprisingly, Jesus was talking about the professional religious authorities; they should have understood the wisdom from the One who truly is able to 'see' – i.e. God – but their own sinful desires and arrogance made them prefer their own wisdom to his. Talking with each other is a fantastic and essential first step but from a Christian perspective there is another step. To borrow the analogy that D. T. Niles used about spreading the gospel message itself: “One beggar telling another where to find bread”, it is essential that we admit our hunger and it is great to know that we are not alone in being hungry, but how much better it is to actually find some bread!
And this links in with my second thought. There was great advice about self-care and how important that is to improving our mental health. And there was also important examples of pressures that can adversely affect mental health. But, how can we make sure that 'self-care' doesn't itself become a pressure that adversely affects mental health? If someone feels that they are a failure in other areas of their life and we tell them to exercise, eat well, get fresh air etc.: if they stop doing that will that compound the feelings of failure they initially had? Hopefully, regular open and honest conversations and practical support will prevent this happening, but it does highlight a particular instance of my previous thought. Self-care is vital but ultimately we are not able to completely help ourselves. The first two Steps of the 12-Step programme of Alcoholics Anonymous are to admit “we were powerless over alcohol – that our lives had become unmanageable” and “that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.” Perhaps mental health is similar: when our lives become unmanageable no amount of self-care can heal us – that can only come from a Power outside of us. As the prayer for the second Sunday of Lent in the Book of Common Prayer says:
Almighty God, who seest that we have no power of ourselves to help ourselves: Keep us both outwardly in our bodies, and inwardly in our souls; that we may be defended from all adversities which may happen to the body, and from all evil thoughts which may assault and hurt the soul
A third thought is to do with one of the aspects of self-care: having a positive outlook about the present. This is, in Henry David Thoreau's famous phrase, about the desire to “suck out all the marrow of life” or in the contemporary phrase YOLO: you only live once. This can often be a self-centred attitude: 'I'll do what pleases/fulfils me' although the four speakers exemplified putting the needs of others before their own. But even if it is done with proper respect for the welfare of others, this attitude fails to acknowledge that life, however well-lived, is ultimately meaningless, if only this life is lived for. Jesus said
Do not store up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moths and vermin destroy, and where thieves break in and steal. But store up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where moths and vermin do not destroy, and where thieves do not break in and steal....do not worry, saying, “What shall we eat?” or “What shall we drink?” or “What shall we wear?”...But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well. (Matthew 6:19-20,31,33)Ambition and purpose are great, but we need to be ambitious for the right things. The things we strive to achieve will ultimately be destroyed, but God's kingdom is eternal, so Jesus encourages us to seek his kingdom and in doing so, what we do becomes eternally meaningful.
My final thought is to do with the day itself. Everything we heard was valuable and useful – but it applies equally to men and to women . Women need to self-care too; women need to seek support; women need to have open and honest conversations. Although it is true that in general men are not as good as women about sharing their struggles and seeking help, we still need to encourage women to do this and to break down barriers that prevent them from seeking support. So on International Men's Day, what could we explore that is specifically about men's mental health? I would suggest that it would be worth exploring a question that was asked but not really addressed, that might be behind some of the struggles that men face with their mental health: what does it mean to be a man? There are many voices online giving conflicting opinions on this, some of which can be very harmful. But perhaps we should turn to our Creator, who tells us not only what it means to be human, but also what it means to be male and female. Genesis 1-3 gives us a great starting point, but it is in Jesus himself that we see not only what perfect humanity looks like, but also what manliness looks like. John Newton's hymn 'How sweet the name of Jesus sounds' describes Jesus like this:
Dear Name, the Rock on which I build,
My Shield and Hiding Place...
Jesus! my Shepherd, Brother, Friend,My Prophet, Priest and King,
My Lord, my Life, my Way, my End
To anyone, but perhaps particularly men, who struggle with mental health may I commend Jesus as the one you can always talk to, even about your deepest fears and anxieties. And he is the one who can heal even your deepest wounds.
Getting Support
www.samaritans.org or phone 116 123
For safeguarding issues:
Free, independent, confidential support for adults affected by church-related abuse:
Safe Spaces helpline on 0300 303 1056 or visit safespacesenglandandwales.org.uk.
Local Authority: safeguarding
• Lincolnshire = 01522 782333
• North East Lincs = 01472 326292 (option 2).
• North Lincs = 01724 296555 (answerphone)

No comments:
Post a Comment